Skip to main content

She Plays With Dolls


girl hugging baby doll by Sarah Rypma

Aisha (ra) was noted to play with dolls. Aisha reported: I used to play with dolls in the presence of the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, and my girlfriends would play with me. When the Messenger of Allah would enter, they would hide themselves but he would call them to join me and play with me. Source: Sahih Bukhari 5779

Aisha (ra) stands out as a model wife and is often noted as being Prophet Mohammed's (pbuh) favourite and therefore worthy of close study of the qualities that made her such. A popular fact about Aisha (ra) is that she played with dolls. The purpose of hadiths are to transmit the sunnah for the benefit of mankind down through the ages. “Whosoever followed the Messenger, has indeed followed Allah.” (Surah an-Nisa, 80) What can we learn from a hadith describing a young girl at play? Doll play is more than a fun pass-time for little girls. It has multiple developmental and psychological benefits. Pretending allows a child to practice looking at things from other perspectives. According to Harvard developmental psychologist Paul Harris, PhD, the thought processes involved in roll-play require children to make predictions about others actions and thoughts. Conventional theories of play therapy study how it affects cognitive skills, language, nurturing, managing environment and emotions. An examination of Aisha's (ra) life and trials through the lens of play therapy can teach us many practical life lessons that we can reflect upon and emulate today.

Nurturing
Perhaps an obvious aspect of playing with dolls is that it develops nurturing. By carrying, holding, feeding, and rocking a baby doll, children are practising being loving to others. We can imagine Aisha and her friends modelling how they were taken care of by their mothers. Aisha's mother Umm Rooman, was a beautiful example of motherhood. Muhammad 'Ali Qutb's book Women Around the Messenger discusses several historically documented accounts of her good character such as her delight and acceptance of her daughter's betrothal to our Prophet (pbuh), her wisdom in nursing Aisha back to health by feeding her cucumber and fresh dates, and the way she stood by her daughter during the time of slander. We see in this mother of four someone who was patient, nurturing and knew when to speak and spoke wisely. Aisha certainly practised reflecting her mother's good character later in life. Az-Zhuri said “The first person to remove distress from the people and explain to them the Sunnah regarding that was Aisha”. 
 
Language
As for language skills, the roll play between dolls and children expands and extends children's vocabulary. There is an easy and organic flow and exchange of words and their meaning as girls verbally interact with each other through the play of their dolls. This practise not only enriches vocabulary, it also encourages dialogue useful for building on more sophisticated discourse as the child matures. Az-Zhuri said “If Aisha's knowledge is compiled and compared to the knowledge of all women her knowledge will surely excel theirs”.
Aisha is known for narrating 2210 hadiths on matters related to the Prophet's private life, as well as topics such as inheritance, pilgrimage and destiny. She passed on her knowledge through several avenues. Her intellect and knowledge in various subjects, including poetry and medicine, were highly praised by early luminaries such as al-Zhuri and her student Urwa ibn al-Zubayr. Urwah ibn al-Zubayr ibn al-'Awwam al-Asadi, Aisah's nephew, was among the seven jurists who formulated the fiqh of Medina in the time of the Tabi'in and one of the Muslim historians.

Managing Emotions and Environment
According to Virginia Axline, child centered play therapy focuses on the child, not on the child’s presenting problem. The child has a chance to follow their own emotional health and work through any problem solving thereby affording the child a sense of control. During the time of slander, Aisha endured very real emotional upset. She knew that anything she said in honesty or if she were to admit an untruth, there would be no recompense of belief in her words alone. Her thought in her time of sorrow and great need was to turn to Allah. 
 
So now, if 1 tell you that 1 am innocent, and Allah knows that 1 am innocent, you will not believe me; and if 1 confess something, and Allah knows that I am innocent of it, you will believe me. By Allah, 1 cannot find of you an example except that of Joseph's father: 'So (for me) patience is most fitting against that which you assert and it is Allah (Alone) Whose help can be sought.'

Our Prophet (pbuh) then received a revelation that unconditionally proved Aisha's innocence. So Allah revealed, 'Verily! Those who spread the Slander are a gang among you. Think it not...' And what did Aisha do? She didn't run to her husband to thank him for his forgiveness, she reserved her thanks for Allah.

Don't Stop Playing
Axline wrote, “Non-directive counseling is really more than a technique. It is a basic philosophy of human capacities, which stresses the ability within the individual to be self-directive” (Axline, 1947; pg. 26).
Play is not just for kids; it is an important source of relaxation and stimulation for adults as well. Playing with your romantic partner, friends, co-workers and children is a sure way to fuel your imagination, creativity, problem-solving abilities, and emotional well-being. Physical play releases endorphins which provide an overall sense of well-being as well as temporary pain relief. There are reports about Aisha playing and watching games with Prophet Mohammed (pbuh).

`A’ishah reported that she accompanied the Prophet in a travel when she was still slim. The Prophet told people to move forward and then he asked `A’ishah to race with him. They had a race and `A’ishah won. In a later travel, when `A’ishah had forgotten the race and had already gained weight, the Prophet told her to race with him again. She declined, “How can I race with you while I am in such a condition?” The Prophet insisted and they did have a race. The Prophet won this time. He laughed then and said, “tit for tat”. (Authenticated by Al-Albani)

The benefit of friendly competition includes accountability and motivation to help someone achieve goals. The close relationship Aisha had with our Prophet (pbuh) allowed for a support system perhaps to keep her motivated to stay healthy. Today we are encouraged to have “exercise buddies” someone who will be a support to us and whom we can support in the mutual goal of physical health. Thinking of your competition as a resource instead of a rival creates meaningful victories that are satisfying in the long run.

`A’isha reported: It was the day of `Eid and some Ethiopians were playing with shields and spears. Either I requested Allah’s Messenger or he himself asked me whether I would like to see the display. I replied in the affirmative. Then he let me stand behind him; my cheek was touching his cheek and he was saying, “Carry on, O Bani Arfida!” When I got tired, he asked me if that was enough. I replied in the affirmative and he told me to leave. (Al-Bukhari)

Notice that Aisha was given a choice as to whether she would like to view the play fighting or not. When Prophet Mohammed (pbuh) sensed that she may be tired, he again gave her the choice to spectate or not. Aisha could practice self-determination in both instances. She could also enjoy the tactics involved in battle vicariously and learn in a non-threatening way what combat was about. The human capacity to be self-directed expresses itself in the joy of play. The good feeling that you get from playing and laughing stays with you even after play time has ended. Play and laughter help us keep an optimistic outlook through disappointment and loss.
The hadith describing Aisha playing with dolls seems very strange on the surface. It points out a particularly obvious and seemingly mundane fact. I posit that we should remember one thing: Islam is a very practical religion, and a science. Hadiths often show us the tip of the iceberg. What the Ansar may have understood from the hadith, an entire field of psychology endeavors to understand today. Although we cannot go back in time to live and understand like the Ansar did, we can certainly make attempts to see through our modern lens with all our logic and faith to contemplate a truly universal and human meaning beyond the tip of the iceberg.

References:



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why Marry?

I've been trying to create characters for a piece I'm working on and like any writer, I've been digging deep into some personal questions. One of the questions my main character asks is “Why can't I find a good woman to marry me?” This is a tough one. I've been soaking in the tub of hopes and fears, lathered with a scrubby sponge of psychology and finally rinsed off with religion to answer this. The response came to me in the form of another question: “Would you marry you ?” Without becoming egotistical or slipping on the wet floor of self-loathing, what would his answer be? Probably a mixed bag of yes and no. And it's true we have our faults. Looking for that “perfect” person will probably mean he will never get married because there is no perfect person out there. My main character is clearly not willing to settle for just anyone, and so he shouldn't. Neither should the women that he encounters. Standards should play a part in this very import...

Dignity and Social Reform: An Islamic Perspective

dig·ni·ty ˈdiɡnədē/ noun noun: dignity the state or quality of being worthy of honor or respect a sense of pride in oneself; self-respect. Islah or Al-Islah (ألإصلاح ,إصلاح, al-ʾIṣlāḥ ) is an Arabic word usually translated as "reform", in the sense of "to improve, to better, or to put something into a better position." Humans are imbued with an inherent dignity. We have the responsibility to nurture the sense of self-respect inherited since the first man and woman walked the earth. The United Nations Charter and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights state that recognition of the inherent dignity and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation for freedom, justice and peace in the world. For centuries moral and ethical codes were rooted in the fiber of civilization. Rules and standards of conduct like Chivalry, Victorian etiquette and 1950s post war manners give examples of codified moral conduct...